Quote:
Originally Posted by just another ref
People don't like this case play, so ignore it, even though it is quite clearly written.
People, however, do like 4.19.8c, and while the language is considerably more vague, it must be followed every time.
I have never heard a satisfactory explanation of the difference.
|
People do not think it is logical. It is not so much that it is clear, but someone if fouled to many does not make since you would have to charge them with a separate foul. And I cannot think of a situation where a fouled player is not altered in such a way that they would be responsible for another foul either. Yes the play is clear, but it does not make real world sense IMO.
Peace