Quote:
Originally Posted by PeteBooth
Ozzy I'm starting to lean more on the "dark side" and maybe umpiring schools need to change with respect to getting help.
We were "brainwashed' or whatever you want to call it when it came to asking our partner for help. Except for once in a while, it was blasphamy to request help. I'm sure "back in the day" you worked with guys that would not even look at you meaning DON'T ASK ME.
Let's take last nights game. Why should we have to wait for DeMuth to request help. Football officials gather almost all the time and discuss the situation yet in baseball you have to wait for the umpire who made the call to request help on his own, which IMO is ludicrous. Suppose DeMuth actually refused to get help and stuck with the call. There is nothing no-one could do at that point no matter how blatent of a miss.
My brother-in-law is a FED football official and they work in crews and I think it's great. Nothing is perfect but as mentioned above I am now leaning more towards the "dark side" then I used to.
Perhaps with IR umpiring schools will now teach / instruct etc. officials to work as team rather then as individuals and then of coarse the rules need to be re-written which would not be a bad thing.
Pete Booth
|
I hear you Pete. In our day, you put your butt on the line with each call and you better not ask the other guy to do
your job. That's all changed now and it is because schools and clinics have stopped putting the onus of the call on the umpire and instead, put it on the "team". Back then, the onus was on
youto get the call right or die with the call. The youngster of today don't understand this and argue with it because they were never taught this way (unless they were taught be me). They never experience being all alone out there with a bad call and no one to "help".
That is what made us the officials we were because we
didn't want to be hanging out to dry. Times change an sometimes not for the better.
My advice is simple; get the call right and you won't need "board meetings" and IR. You'll still have disagreements but the calls will be solid.