Quote:
Originally posted by Skahtboi
First of all, David, the way that Mike described is the way that obstruction is enforced in every code that I work, which is ASA, NFHS, USSSA and Dixie. (Though Dixie actually wants the umpire to drop a flag when it occurs to denote the delayed dead ball, most umpires use the "normal" delayed dead ball signal.)
I have read and reread this thread, and do not understand what is so difficult about the application of this rule. If a runner is obstructed, she is awarded the base to which the umpire felt she would have made had the obstruction not occurred. What is so difficult about this? Killing the ball right then and there has the potential to punish the offense, which is the side that has been offended, in much the same way that you do not kill the ball immediately on an illegal pitch. (Which is in the event that the batter hits the ball, and could possibly gain more than the penalty prescribes.)
Scott
|
After having it explained, I completely understand how ASA signals and penalizes obstruction on rundowns. You seem to think I don't understand it. I do. I think you're confusing my disagreeing with misunderstanding.
I was simply taking a bit of an incredulous attitude pointing out that ASA isn quite unique in that they allow the play to continue *and* have the option of awarding the obstructed runner to *either* of the bases. Since the umpire does not announce the awarded base along with the infraction (or does he?), the defense is forced to continue playing on the runner to prevent her from scoring (in the event the awarded base is 3rd), and while that is going on ... ultimately, the runner is immune from being put out.
David Emerling
Memphis, TN