Quote:
Originally Posted by La Rikardo
NFHS rules.
1. 3rd and 20 on the A20. A completes a pass for 18 yards to the A38. B is flagged for a DPI foul. May A accept only the automatic first down and not the yardage or must they accept or decline the penalties together?
|
I think what you're asking is can they take the 18 yard reception, refuse the 15 yards and take the auto 1st down. No, they cannot.
They can take the play or the penalty, not both.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jchamp
So am I to understand that the 15 yards of the DPI is declined, but the first down remains? It sounds like a more fair application of the rules, but I've not had this happen to me, where I've had to enforce it.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by CT1
No.
The basic spot for DPI (loose ball play) is the previous spot. A's options are:
(1) Accept the penalty and yardage. 1st-and-10 on the A-35.
(2) Decline the penalty. 4th and 2 on the A-38.
(3) Accept the penalty but decline the yardage. 1st-and-10 on the A-20.
In my game, we won't ever get past Option #1.
|
Disagree.
They can decline the 15 yards but accept the 1st down. However, it will be a 1st down from the previous spot.
And no, there's no real reason to do this.