[bob jenkins]

Originally posted by thumpferee
I'm confused about the fact that there are so many different views of the rule.

The rule is the rule.

Except that there are multiple rules codes.

Rich says it's a balk.

No, Rich says it's a balk in FED -- he's right.

Whowefoolin says pitcher concedes the pick off play when in wind-up position.

Correct -- it doesn't fool anyone at the higher levels because the pick-off move --other than perhaps the leg kick, looks nothing like the normal pitching motion. The (usual) pitching motion has a step back and arm movement other than directly to a throwing position (brought togehter, raised ove the head, etc). The pick-off move needs to be a direect, immediate (don't take these words too literally) step and the arm will go to a thrtowing position (it's not required for a feint, but will be practical for the actual pick-off).

Chris s says it's possible for a righty.

For a righty, it will be easier to have the pick at first. Most pitchers pitch from the set with a runner at first, even if there's also runners at second and third). For a lefty, the move will be easier to third.

You say it's legal.

I say it's legal under NCAA and OBR rules.

I value your interpretation, Bob, but why are we not on same page here as umpires?

I have some ideas, but you'll have to come to your own conclusion.

I assumed there would be a defining answer, but, there I go assuming again!

There is, if the question and answer(s) is (are) properly defined and understood.