Darn it you guys ... I think Im switching sides on this one and will now agree with you. I think I see where I've gone astray here. (With help, thank you) I was originally thinking this play was no different then as if it had happened over at the sideline with the receiver coming down OOB because of the contact. In that case hed get the catch and benefit of his furthest progress. But with him coming down inbounds defiantly changes things. So the A-33 it is. Thanks for having patience with me