[senior]

but for most of us, it's as good as it gets.

There are some problems with any coverage, even four man when they rotate.

Since most of us will never work the upper levels of the game, we have to be content with the hand we're dealt. If I can't expect any help on a play like you described with the question of a possible pulled foot, I would rather work alone, and leave your disagreeable partner find someone else to work with.

The call you described is one which is usually accepted by both teams when cooperation is exhibited by both Umpires.
If, however, for whatever reason you care to state, you do not go for help, you leave the door open for all types of criticism. I believe the modern thinking is to get the call right, and put the ego aside, if needed, to insure it is right. The old school of thought was that you showed some weakness if you got help, the newer thinking is to make the correct call, even if help is required.


Senior