[zm1283]

Originally Posted by just another ref

Here's the problem with the twist. Defender is stationary, with the dribbler coming straight at him. At the last possible moment, naturally, the dribbler makes a move to try and go around. The defender makes the twist described above. He may or may not move a foot. Trouble is, most fans, and, let's face it, some officials, say "He was moving," and call a block.

Also, on a related note, even if the defender doesn't move at all, some think that if the contact is not centered directly on the torso of the defender and the defender doesn't subsequently fall down, it can't be a charge.

Yep. Another common myth. I hear that a lot...."If the defender backs up or doesn't take it right in the chest, it's a block".

Too many officials penalize the defense IMO.