Quote:
Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee
How can he be right? He said "during a held ball". The situation that you described occurred before a held ball("while touching the ball in an attempt to gain full control"...in your words) . They're completely different situations, aren't they?
Pizza and lasagna...
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by just another ref
Nothing happens during a held ball. When a held ball happens, the ball is dead.
|
JAR is correct.
But most people describe the action that precedes the judgment of the ball becoming dead as being "during a held ball".
The FIBA rule is that they want the held ball to be enforced, rather than a violation. So their interp is that once a player commits a violation by stepping out of bounds or by returning to his backcourt, all the while two opponents are still tugging at the ball (but not yet untoward), the play is automatically deemed to be a held ball.