Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnny Ringo
In this particular play, there was little no doubt it was not a pass 
A1 was trying to connect with A2 who had slipped behind the defender. A1 never jumped and made the throw with two hands over the top of his head.
In accordance to NFHS rules, this would be illegal, because it was not a try? What would be the call? |
Little? If there's any
doubt, the accepted practice is to rule it a try. And as I said, unless you're a mind-reader, there always has to be some doubt, no matter how small.
The bottom line on this particular call, Johnny, is that
afaik it's almost universally accepted that anything thrown off their own board should be judged a try. By strict reading of the rule though, you can judge it as being a pass. But there's also the fact that you might be right in theory in judging it a pass but be very, very wrong in real life if you do so. My advice fwiw is that you should find out from someone in your area...assignor, rules interpreter, etc.... how they want you to call this particular play. Don't be "that guy".
Btw, this exact play is currently being discussed on 2 other basketball officiating discussion forums, even as we speak. The almost unanimous consensus seems to be that the
accepted call everywhere is to deem it a try
all the time.