Quote:
Originally Posted by M&M Guy
You may be confusing the definitions of the terms dribble and pass with the generally accepted meanings, and intent of the player. A pass, by rule, is to another player. The fact that you even used quotes to call it a "pass" when the same player retrieved it shows you have the rule confused with intent.
|
I may have confused some of you with my "pass" notation. The quotes basically said "for the the lack of a better word," but I know it's wrong.
Quote:
|
The ball doesn't have to go in a direct line from the hand to the floor, but can even go up in the air, as long as it's allowed to hit the ground before being touched again (4-15-2)
|
Actually, that's my point, and it's all about the definition, not the general acceptance. My understanding of the OP was that ball was never allowed to hit the floor, so it wouldn't meet the definition of a dribble, either. If it hits the floor, that's a different story.
Quote:
|
in the OP, it wasn't a pass.... It wasn't a fumble.... It wasn't a try.... So that makes the player's action a dribble, by rule.
|
So, if it's not A, nor B, nor C, then it must be D, even though the action doesn't meet the definition of D? Is there a rule the cites this?
Quote:
|
I wonder if my boss would mind if I took some additional bookshelf space for more basketball-related items?
|
I've wondered that myself.
For now, I keep mine in a desk drawer.
Aside to Nevada: Do you have that recent case in question? That may put this whole argument to bed.