Note: This is speaking ASA based on comment about what ASA teaches.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by mbcrowder
How can it be a missed base - to miss a base, you have to pass it without hitting it.
|
Citations please. But for the sake of argument, say the player was already heading that way and just ran passed on the way to the 3B dugout. Is there also a rule which dictates how close a runner must come to this base for it to be missed?
Think about that statement. If a runner goes directly from 3B to 1B on a caught fly ball, are you not allowing the appeal at 2B because the runner did not physically pass the base?
Quote:
|
If you are calling this a missed base in THIS case, are you implying that you would not call the out for abandoning the basepaths if this happened in the middle of the game when R1's run didn't appear to end the game? No - BU would rule that runner out for ABANDONMENT (Yes, it's usually a crutch, but for once it's the proper ruling) when they entered the dugout. You can't call it abandonment in one case, but insist on an appeal for a missed base in another.
|
I didn't state that I insisted on an appeal, did I?
My question was based on your statement that ASA teaches that only the BR and scoring runner is the concern. I've never heard such a thing. The importance of the scoring runner is obvious. But why wouldn't all other runners carry the same importance whether BR, R2 or R3?
Quote:
|
I ask again ... by what rule are you disallowing this run?
|
Where did I state that I was?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dakota
It wasn't a missed base; it was failure to advance. So, call the runner out for failure to advance.
|
How do you know it wasn't a missed base? Cite the definition of a "missed base". And please cite the rule where it states a runner is out for failing to advance?
Quote:
|
Now, find the rule that removes the run from the board
|
If necessary, I will
