|
I think its a tough call no matter what you do, but in situations 1-6 on sliding, If the runner made no attempt to get up and go to another base, and he would have been safe if the base was still there, I would probably kill the play and put the runner back at third. One of the things that a fixed base does when you slide is help you stop, I don't think you can penalize the player for sliding into a base and taking it with him, no matter how far across he/she slides, especially on a hook slide or or when diving to a corner of the bag to avoid a tag. One of the things I've done and been told when playing is that if you slide and that bag moves away or dislodges, just stay where you are and don't try to go to where the bag is, and hope the ump will protect you.
In the others, when the base dislodges, I think you have to give the benefit of the doubt to the runner, as a ruuner you are taught, and it becomes instinct after a while to always go to the bag. I think it is quite a bit to ask from a runner to stop int he middle of what they are doing and try to decide if the bag is in the right spot or not. Like in situation number 10, how is the runner supposed to know that f6 moved the bag when trying to go out and make the play, I'm not watching fielders make plays, I've got my head down and running hard, how can you call the runner out for that?
I think no matter what you guys decide to do, just be consistent with it and let the players know at the beginning of every game how you are going to be calling the dislodged base. Another thing I have seen done is to get a can of field paint or chalk, and spray or chalk the the spot where the base is supposed to be. On a slide, you will probably have to redo the markings, but it would help eliminate the problems of the runner dislodging the bases, cause they should know where the origianl spot is.
|