I have a buddy that has a pair and swears by them. I bought a pair, put them on once and sent them back. I didn't like the feel or the way the cover attaches. It didn't want to stay in place when it was on and looked horrible when it was off. It leaves an inch to inch and one half piece of velcro on the shoe.
I prefer the Hoenig low top. If you order it order a size small.