Quote:
Originally Posted by UmpJM (nee CoachJM)
No member of the defense had possession of the ball and no throw was in progress. The ball was "loose".
|
John, you have the facts correct, of course. But consider the following scenario: the play develops just as in the OP, except for the end.
1. F5 releases the runner as F6 picks up the loose ball, and then
2. F6 tags the runner before he can get back to 3B.
On your interp, you must call this Type B OBS and protect the runner back to 3B. You're calling it Type B because at the moment when the OBS took place no member of the defense had possession of the ball, and so there was no play on the runner.
The defense played on the runner immediately before and immediately after the OBS in my modified scenario. For me, that's sufficient to rule this Type A and award the runner home. For me, this ruling is most consistent with the spirit of the distinction between Type A and Type B OBS.