Quote:
Originally Posted by Dakota
First of all, it was not an appeal. It was an umpire going to his partner for help on a call. Even though it is commonly called an appeal, it is not an appeal play.
Second, a BR was out for the third out before reaching 1B. No runs score.
Third, in the situation presented, why did the PU even ask his partner about the swing?  |
First of all, excellent point.
Second, the call of strike 3 and the fact that there was a dropped third strike is what made the batter a BR. But, doesn't she still need to be retired? Of the fact that she walked away from the plate, but perhaps not into DB territory, is that sufficient action to declare her out?
Third, cuz it was the right thing to do? If he denied, it would have meant at least the 1 run that scored and who knows what might have happened on another pitch.
Ted