Interesting differentiation,
I'm at work and without a rule book and since I'm not working HS ball this year I have not studied up on NFHS --
It seems in NFHS's effort to write it a different way, they (IMO inadvertantly) change entire interpretations.
This is the same thing as leaving "play" out of interference.
I still got a noncall, if I'm on the field right now, and i guess the wrong call.. but I'm not calling OBS on a fielder in the immediate act of fielding a batted ball.
The ONLY reason step and reach is an issue ever is because the fielder is relocating, conceivably into a new new path, and receiving further/extra protection -
To me, since deflection is not the issue - the fielder still in the same position immediately after the miss (ie a dive, or bending over whatever - still in the immediate act - although ultimately unsucessful) that is still fielding the ball.
Since NFHS is not interested in "fielding the ball" I suppose I should bow out of the discussion and leave it to you NFHS gurus.
__________________
ASA, NCAA, NFHS
Last edited by wadeintothem; Wed Mar 04, 2009 at 02:35pm.
|