Quote:
Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA
Why? Is there some secret rule that states a player must keep possession for a certain period of time after the tag is applied? Citations, please.
Who cares where the umpire was looking when the ball came out of the mitt? The umpire was in perfect position. Saw the tag by the catcher with possession of the ball and made the call. Any subsequent action is irrelevant to the tag and out call. As stated often in this discussion, do not confuse a "catch" with a "tag", it is not the same.
|
Oh don't get me wrong... I think he got the call right. And please don't patronize me - you know as well as I do that there's no time frame.
There is absolutely a reason to keep your eyes on the rest of the play. Why do you think we're taught to not turn our head on a 3K sell out with runners on base?
All I'm saying here is that IMO, Wilke turned away from the play to make his call, and probably didn't see the ball come loose, for whatever reason - ground, bag, bobble, interference, whatever. Did him looking away affect the call? No.