View Single Post
  #68 (permalink)  
Old Fri Apr 18, 2008, 08:53pm
Mark Dexter Mark Dexter is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Aug 1999
Posts: 4,801
Quote:
Originally Posted by Coach Bill
To Mark Dexter: "But when they saw A1 step off the court, they didn't know that there were still five players left. IMO, no T in this case."

Wouldn't you have either:

1. Too many players
As I said before - this one is only a T if it's discovered while being violated. If a kid runs off the floor, then you count five on the court, you didn't discover it while there were six on the court. No T.

Quote:
2. A player voluntarily leaving the playing court.
Might be a violation, but leaving the floor for an unauthorized reason is no longer penalized with a technical foul.

Quote:
3. A player away from the bench area.
First off, check your definitions. Other than during intermissions and timeouts, players should generally be off the bench. Second, even if he were a substitute, the T is for leaving a bench area during a fight. Otherwise, we'd have a T whenever the JV players left to dress for the varsity game.

Quote:
Aren't these all cases for a 'T'? You had to have something.
All I have is a "sorry, coach, we didn't see him when he was out on the court."

Quote:
And, the refs admitted they saw him, but "He got off the court quickly, so we let it go". I got the 'T' for unsportingly asking "How can you just ignore the rules like that!!!"
Now we're talking differently. If they knew six were out on the court, but chose not to call it, you have a semi-legitimate beef. If they truly didn't even think to count until A6 ran off (which is what I assumed in my answers above), then there's nothing they can do. If a T is called, A's coach is going to have the right to go ballistic for ignoring the rules.
__________________
"To win the game is great. To play the game is greater. But to love the game is the greatest of all."
Reply With Quote