[wadeintothem]

I've had the same play with the same coach going ballistic more than a few times.. and it pretty much sucks when only a few could be in position to see it.. but thats why you are there.

You made the right call.

Your partner is full of it.

And pay no mind the the appeal thing, its really stretching it to try to make this an appeal play as described. On any type of wide slide, hook slide etc, its when they touch the bag.. not pass the plate/base.