Quote:
|
Originally Posted by jer166
IMO it doesn't matter whether it is 9-2-3 or 9-2-11. Either way it is a throw-in violation and according to the 9-2 PENALTY (section 2) the ball is awarded to the opponents for a throw in at the original throw-in spot.
|
Uh, if you're talking about my revised case, you're incorrect. One is an only OOB violation. The real question is not attempting to address whether to call the violation on A2 for being OOB during a spot throwin (clearly this happens before anything else and there is no complication). The real question that needs to be answered is what to call when A2 is legally OOB (but also touching inbounds) when they catch a thrown ball on the OOB side of the throwin plane. You've got three choices: (1) OOB violation on A2, (2) Throwin violation for A2 catching the ball on the OOB side of the throwin plane, and (3) throwin violation for A2 carrying the throwin onto the court (A2 is a thrower who should have been entirely OOB).
All are violations that give B the ball, but #1 and #3, give them the ball at the point of the touch where the other is the point of the throw.