[Jay R]

Originally Posted by t-rex

Was this an error by the umpires, or by the official scorer and the Blue Jays?

The MLB Gameday report for the bottom of the second has this reported as a ground out by Hill to the catcher. Of course, it should have been recorded as a putout of Zaun by the catcher.

The next batter, as we all know, should be McDonald. Would the umpires tell Toronto who to send to the plate next, or do they remain silent to the fact that Toronto is still BOO?

The home plate umpire pointed to Hill and gave the out signaled. They just goofed. Nothing else.