Quote:
|
Originally Posted by CecilOne
I understand theapplication of the rule, but maybe not the semantics of this discussion. Please help me follow how a fake throw is an
" attempt by a defensive player to retire a batter-runner or runner"
if the
" movement could not reasonably lead to a possible out".  |
Instead of taking partial comments out of multiple posts, let's just address what I stated
Quote:
|
In ASA, it must be an attempt to retire a runner or BR. IOW, if the movement could not reasonably lead to a possible out, it is not a play.
|
I've never said that a "fake throw" was not a play. Obviously, if the pitcher released the ball, the runner could be put out, hence it meets the definition of "play".
That doesn't mean that any movement by the pitcher is a fake throw or a play. A pitcher "rolling" the ball in her hand by her side is movement, but not a play. A pitcher moving the ball back and forth between the hand and glove is a movement, but not a play.