Quote:
Originally posted by BktBallRef
Clearly, in this play, the ball is bouncing inbounds... BTW, Mr. Knox does not disagree with my interpretation of this play. When a member of the throwing team knocks the ball OOB, it is most definitely at the disposal of the thrower and it is now live.
|
Of course Mr. Knox doesn't disagree, because you have misrepresented the situation:
Please ask Mr. Knox whether a ball IB is at disposal. I would love to get an e-mail from him on this matter.
And, the case book play says near the end-line, but it does not say IB, is that UNAMBIGUOUS?.
The reason this has gone on 5 pages is that certain posters continue to repeat the same things over and over; and they (except Padgett) refuse to answer basic questions like: Isn't it a violation to carry a live ball OOB?