Quote:
|
Originally Posted by phansen
Defender is set and stationary when the offensive player dribbling the ball runs into the defender. Offensive player bounces off the defender and goes to the ground, while the defender is still standing in the same position.
|
Maybe I'm too old-fashioned (I certainly can't say old school anymore), but this has to be a charge. Defender is not moving and is occupying a space on the floor. Offensive player is attempting to occupy that space with such force that he falls to the floor. How can this be incidental contact?
You are reading too much into the advantage/disadvantage aspect. If a HS player runs into you with enough force that he himself falls down, that
hurts. Even if you never played the game, you must have had a player run into you at some point in your career. Ouch!
If pain isn't disadvantageous to playing basketball, I don't know what is.
I understand those who say they'd have to see the play, but this is obvious to me.
If you no-call this, I can almost guarantee that game is going to start going downhill. Keep your eyes open for chippy play.