Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Jimgolf
1. 5-10-1 does not apply here, because there is no definite knowlege to correct the count. Therefore if the shot counts and there are to be free throws, the clock would be set to 0, and the lane cleared. do we agree on this much?
2. 6-7-6 does not apply, since time has not expired. The timer has sounded the horn in error. Time does not expire when the horn is sounded erroneously with one minute left, why would it expire when the horn is sounded in error with an undetermined amount of time left?
3. 6-7-7 A foul other than player or team control has occured, so we review the exceptions
4. Since time has not expired, the conditions in exception c are met, so the basket counts and the free throws should be awarded.
"c. Article 7 occurs by any opponent of a player who has started a try or tap for goal (is in the act of shooting) before the foul occurred, provided time did not expire before the ball was in flight."
|
1) No. 5-10-1 DOES apply because it says you can't put ANYTHING back on the clock unless you know EXACTLY how much TIME to put on the clock. You also can't count a shot that wasn't in the air when the horn went.
2) Cite a rule telling me why 6-7-6 doesn't apply? According to the original post, time DID expire before the ball was in the air.
3) OK...let's review.
4) Um, the original post said that time did expire though before the ball was in the air, which is why (c) is applicable.
Again, you have NO rules backing to do what you want to do.