Quote:
|
Originally Posted by just another ref
Also, I have been scolded at higher levels for knowing how many fouls a player had. The theory is that this knowledge might subconsciously change a potential call, which is possible. But if a player picks up multiple fouls close together, especially if it is the star, how can anybody watching the game not know?
|
There is some truth to that. Of course, the true official is one who is of strong enough character that he will still make what he believes to be the right call despite the situation or the consequences.
You are also absolutely right that the star player knows how many fouls he has, his coach knows, the opponents certainly know, and likely everyone in the building who is a knowledgable fan knows. So why shouldn't the official know too? The fact is that he does. He is a human. Until the game is officiated by robots, there will be normal human influences in calling it.
I once spoke with a Supreme Court Justice regarding the pressures felt by them in making decisions on social issues. He acknowledged that he did the best he could to view these issue intellectually and fulfill his role as a judge, but that people do not live their lives in a vacuum and that SCJs, just like anyone else, are susceptible to these same pressures. These people live in the community, have neighbors, friends, and socialize with the people around them. Their children attend the same schools.
I learned a great deal from my talks with this person.
I believe that the same applies to sports officials. Knowledge is a good thing, just be sure to use it wisely.