An interesting dilema. And here is an odd twist...
I don't have a 2006 book handy, but I do have the 2005 book on CD with me now.
For the 2006 rule, is the above quote from "blue" accurate? Does the "NOTE" associated with 7-4-E really say that a ball hit on the backswing is ruled as "...a strike and a DEAD BALL"?
My 2005 book reads that it is "...a strike and a FOUL BALL".
A subtle editorial change? A misquote from "blue"?
If this is an editorial change, it is one that would have a profound effect on how this rule is enforced. It almost looks like someone caught this inconsistency, slipped the editorial change in the new book, but forgot to make a corresponding change to the conflicting rule (7-6-K-3).
In other words, it looks like somebody already tinkered with this, but they just didn't tinker enough!
Last edited by BretMan; Thu Sep 14, 2006 at 12:38pm.
|