Quote:
|
Originally Posted by fwump
I've read numerous threads on this site debating the differences between so called "LL" or "small diamond baseball" umpires verses "real" umpires who call on 90' diamonds with shaving aged players.
I propose this: If you have the skill sets and the training to be successful at the HS, college or adult level, then you will perform well on any size diamond regardless. All other debate on the subject is pretty much useless.
I have been at it for over eight years now, calling youth, senior league, HS and NABA. (NO LL for me, I like getting paid). I can confirm through experience that there are terrible umpires out there at ALL levels of baseball. And some of the worst are calling HS JV. (At least down here in north TX).
However, if you have not, for whatever reason, worked higher level baseball at at least HS varsity level or above, then you will never gain the right to proclaim yourself a "real" umpire. I do not consider myself there yet. Thats why I lurk here to try and learn something.
Just my opinion
Mike
|
I personally do not like to make generalizations.
IMO, Umpiring is all about one's goals and availability.
I worked exclusively LL baseball in my early career. Not because I didn't want to advance but because it fit my work schedule. I could not get out of work in time to make HS games.
Also, in LL their is 90ft. baseball so I gained some experience that way.
When one works HS games, you need a job that fits. You see teachers, postal workers, policemen/ Firemen, sales type people or individuals who have their won business primarily at the HS level because they have a job that fits.
It wasn't until I worked in my job for several years, became a good employee and then was able to "work around" my job to do HS ball.
IMO, the term "REAL UMPIRE" is an umpire who
1. Looks the part meaning they are properly dressed
2. Reads the rule-book
3. Attends some form of mechanics training and
4. Takes pride in what they do no matter what the level of ball.
Pete Booth