[Andy]

Some very good comments here, let me add my two cents.

This play is one of the biggest flaws in the two umpire system. The BU has a crappy angle and a long distance to call the pickoff at first. The PU has a better angle, but also has a batter and catcher to work around and monitor their actions after the pitch. The PU also has to be aware of the runner on second and be ready to cover the play at third is she breaks on the attempted pickoff at first.

One thing you can do to help with this play is what has been called "working between pitches". In the C position with runners on first and second, once the pitch has not been hit, start taking a few steps into the infield and "read" the catcher. If she throws to first for the pickoff, you are already moving that direction and can get closer to the play to make your call. You may still have the same crappy angle, but by being closer to the play, you give the appearance that you are hustling to be in the best position possible to make the call. This can go a long way in helping you sell that call.

This is the BUs call. Make the best call you can with the information you have. If requested, you may want to ask your partner for help. The proper way to do this is to get together with your partner away from any coaches or players and converse amongst yourselves. The question I will usually ask is: "OK partner, I have a ____ call, did you see anything different?" Get your partners input then either change your initial call or stick with it.

My advice to you, as a new umpire, would be to study the rules, mechanics, signals, and positioning of umpiring. These are the foundation of our craft. Once you have those down solid, you can start adding the little things like I have outlined above to enhance your appearance and credibility. Being in a HS Varsity game your first year out is tough, but keep working on making yourself a better umpire.