Quote:
Originally posted by RookieDude
Believe it or not...we have a NCAA official that used to be a member of our H.S. association, who now has moved on and done a few NCAA championship games. (Dick Cartmell)
A few of us H.S. officials met for some refreshments after our games last Friday night and ran into Mr. Cartmell.
Dick said that while he was at the Maui Classic...a question was posed to the officials...and he was wondering what we thought.
The question seemed simple enough, but we had some lively debate.
Question:
Team A scores...player B1 grabs the ball after the made basket and throws the ball to B2 before B1 goes OOB for the endline throw-in. Is this a "do-over" or a violation?
I said it would be a violation...Dick said that the officials at the tourney decided it would be a "do-over".
9.2.2 SITUATION C, covers NFHS ruling.
Is the NCAA ruling different?
BTW, I told him about this site...and said I would check on the ruling with the big dogs here. I'll see him next week, as I am part of a crew that will be doing his son's H.S. game.
|
It would definitely depend on the level and flow of the game. In any middle school game, except a travelling team regional championship, it would be a do-over. Above that, I've got a judgment call.
But if Cartmell were to personally ask me (yea, like that's ever gonna happen!!), I'd say, "Hm, Let me see. Did anyone talk about junior high?" and then listen to other people's opinions about hs and NCAA. In that crowd, I'm still a learner.