Quote:
Originally posted by ChuckElias
Quote:
Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
Quote:
Originally posted by bjb3
A1 is erroneously awarded a 1 and 1. A-1 makes the first. A-1's second FT misses. As B-1 is rebounding B-1 is fouled by A-2. The error is now recognized.
Official cancels the FT and cancels the common foul. Is the official correct?
|
we don't know whether A2 committed that common foul before or after the FT ended(R4-20-3)- because "as B1 is rebounding" doesn't really give us that info.
|
No, but doesn't "A1's second FT misses" give us that info?
|
Fine, as long as the foul occurred on B1
after the FT missed, that's enough info. Does the question definitively say that though? B1 coulda been in the lane in rebounding mode with the FT bouncing around on the rim before falling off,
n'est-ce,pas?.
Or......I'm being too anal....again.