[JRutledge]

I think there are very select amateur umpires that could step in and work games at that level and perform just as good if not better than a few select MLB Umpires. That does not mean most or all could make that transition. The major difference between a pro umpire and an amateur umpire is the route they choose to take. I saw some calls in the playoffs just yesterday that looked like "rookie" mistakes on calls that I know certain umpires would not make. Let us face it, working the bases are not the most difficult thing for an umpire to do. Most of the time we sit around and have to make one call, especially if we are working more than 2 Man mechanics. All the 3 Man games I worked this past season I was lucky to get one really close call, let alone a tough call. I think the hardest transition would be for someone to work the plate. I just think it is not out of the realm of possibility that amateurs would do a good job if they are given a chance. I feel the same way that if you gave amateurs in my other sports, some would be able to handle working the. The difference is the individuals at the pros were given a chance or pursue that level. Not everyone can pursue the pros.

Peace