Quote:
Originally posted by Love this Game
Quote:
Originally posted by blindzebra
LTG, you have yet to give anything to support your position that this rule is unfair to the defense.
Isn't the entire purpose of defense, from a player's point of view, to stop the other team from scoring and get the ball?
Does this rule in anyway interfere with that purpose?
As several posters have explained, how is a TC foul any different than a PC foul?
Why should which offensive player has the ball matter?
If anything it requires better defense to draw a PC foul, so why isn't that call more unfair?
This rule may come up so rarely that it is so, a non-issue. I have officated about 100 games this summer with TC fouls in the rules and we have called it 3 times with team B in the bonus. At least 1,500 to 2,000 foul calls and it was an issue THREE TIMES.
|
A3 sets a screen on B1, B1 runs over A3, A3 shoots if in the bonus.
A3 sets a screen on B1, as B1 runs around A3 moves into B1 and knocks B1 down all B1 gets is the ball.
I am finished you all have a nice day and evening
But You are correct 
[Edited by Love this Game on Aug 1st, 2005 at 07:45 PM]
|
A1 crashes into B1 while going up to shoot, B gets the ball no FTs.
A1 crashes into B1 just after releasing the try, B gets the ball no FTs.
A1 crashes into B1 just after passing to A2, why should this play be any different than the first two?