Wow, Jo McCain, I have never seen an offensive player fake someone poking him/her in the ribs.

I guess I've never seen an offensive player fake it when someone actually makes contact with them ever. Just kidding.
It is up to all of us what we allow in our game and what we don't allow. If we are talking about whether a handcheck re-routes a player or not we could be consistent to see the play through. Mr McCain's example isn't really about seeing the whole play IMO, it is more about eliminating some BS early in the game.