[SRW]

http://spysoftball.com/world_series_notes.htm

THE CONTROVERSY

Readers have asked for more detail on the two plays which resulted in two UCLA palyers reaching 1st – which started the Bruins’ five-run 6th inning.

Andrea Duran, leading off, claims she was struck by a pitch. But, home plate umpire Willie Newman said he didn’t see the hit. Newman ruled a foul ball, count 0-2. Bruin coach Sue Enquist asked Newman to consult with the other two umpires – 60 feet away. Newman reversed himself, and Duran was awarded 1st.

The next batter, slapper Tara Henry, fouled off an 0-2 pitch. This time, Michigan coach Carol Hutchins, who thought Henry had bunted and would be out on the third strike bunt rule, asked Newman for help – but this time Newman said he didn’t need any help – Henry in his opinion did not swing.

In the press box, where the play reviewed was reviewed on camera, several reporters thought Henry appeared to have “broken” her wrists, ie, she bunted rather than slapped. But, Newman’s view prevailed. Henry grounded to Grace Leutele at 3rd who bobbled the ball, and both runners were safe – and eventually scored.

Later, the UIC, Jeff Hansen, told some reporters the key variable in a bunt or swing call is whether a hitter “hinges” their wrist or has a swinging motion.

In the end it didn’t matter – except as one of the endless arguments about umpire calls.

It didn’t matter because Anjelica Selden and the UCLA defense were overwhelming. No Wolverine reached 2nd base.