Yes sir you are correct, I agree with your post to Tony. The runner should be put on third base. I think I stated this in my post before so I'm not as far off as you seem to think. But would you award home even if you though she would only have gotten third? The point I was making is you don't get an bonus base because you were OBSed. Award only the base you judge they would have gotten had not been OBS. One question, had this happend in a game you were umpiring, what action would you take toward the 1st baseman?