....I've found that position B does put you in the best position for one thing on that steal of second -- the swipe tag by F4/F6 from behind R1 on that wide throw (to the plate side).
However, when I work three or four man and I'm the guy at second making the call, I ALWAYS work deep C. Carl is right -- having the play open to you rather than having the throw turn you is much preferable.
(Another) However, most associations are going to want you in B, so let's talk position B.
It is crucial that you are in the right position, equidistant between the mound and second base. Many umpires set up too far in towards the plate or too far towards first base.
If there is a pickoff to first, your step should be FORWARD towards the plate, not towards first. I use one big step forward with my left foot, on which heel I then turn. Step and turn on my heel. Nothing more. Unless the runner was leaning and still "swimming" for the base coming back or unless he has a massive coronary and dies before returning to first, you will likely call the runner safe. Chalk this up as a limitation of the two-man system.
If there is a steal of second, try to get two or three quick, large backwards steps towards the base before the ball reaches (and turns) you. After the ball turns you and before the fielder catches the ball, come set.
In most cases, if the ball beats the runner and the glove is put down, the runner should be called out. Unless the fielder makes a horrible tag or if it is obvious that the runner made a heroic effort in avoiding the tag (hook sliding to the back of the base, for example), make the out call.
Rich
--------------
eContact, eUmpire
[email protected]