Sun Feb 13, 2005, 09:32pm
|
|
Official Forum Member
|
|
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 2,674
|
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Dan_ref
Quote:
Originally posted by blindzebra
You are like talking to a freaking rock, I quoted the stupid rule that said ONLY A TIMER'S ERROR MAY BE CORRECTED.
I'm done, you are wrong, and it is obvious you will NEVER get it.
|
Wait.
Maybe I missed something but didn't you tell me that in my sitch you would correct an obvious OFFICIAL'S error?? Let's go to the videotape:
Quote:
Originally posted by Dan_Ref
Look, I tried to uncomplicate this with a simple play. You continue to keep it complicated. So let's try 1 more time. No foul. No running the endline. A simple throw-in by A1 on his endline with seconds left in the game. And the T decides to chop in time as he bounces the ball to A1 for the throw-in and the horn goes off to end the game as A1 catches the ball for the throw-in. We have an official's error which you claim cannot be corrected. So by rule, you claim, the game's over.
You are R. What do you do? Don't quote me any rules, let's pretend I'm Coach A and you just cost me a playoff spot. You going to explain to me on the court why the game is over? Or you gonna wait for me to come banging on the locker room door?
Quote:
Originally posted by blindzebra
What do the officials in case play 5.10.1.C say?
Fairness and explanations aside, your play is no different than 5.10.1.C.
By rule the game is over and that is all you can tell them.
In practice I'm giving a do-over, just like in the play that started this thread.
I don't think it is supported by rule, but it is the fair thing to do, so I'm fudging with 2-3.
|
|
Yeah, looks like you would set aside your rule for my case. What gives??
|
I said I would do what is fair even though it is not supported by rule.
The other side is incorrectly saying that IT CAN BE FIXED by rule 5-10. There is no rule support to fix this situation.
|