Thread: 0 or 00
View Single Post
  #71 (permalink)  
Old Mon Jan 31, 2005, 10:07pm
totalnewbie totalnewbie is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 149
JR-

Thanks for the reply. Look, dont mistake my devil's advocate position and request for feedback as me saying I love that T. I dont.

I am trying to find the personal philosophy for why I do or dont pass on a T.

We'll probably all agree on this: if it is in the book as a foul or violation, it should be called, particularly if advantage/disadvantage is gained.

Now not a single one of us, I would imagine, actually does this. We all use our discretion. Which is what we are supposed to do.

Heck, I passed on 10 travels last game alone and a some silly hand contact by girls that cant play good defense. And the book didnt have starters 10 minutes before and I didnt T that up either. And when a girl used hands on a cutter I didnt ring her up. Instead I said "watch the hands 32" because the pass didnt come down into the paint it went across the perimiter. No advantage/disadvantage. And at the end of the game when the girl grabbed an arm or waist to take a foul and put the otehr team on the line I said it was close enough to playing the ball and I called a regular foul, not an intentional.

But what are YOUR personal parameters of that discretion? I am trying to find mine. That is why I want feedback on this.

I like the idea of making sure you make calls that are respected so that when things get tight and you have to make a tough charge call on the home team you can make it and it will be recieved right and that way the focus is oon the game and not your calls. I get that. But where do you draw that line? How do YOU balance the need to have your calls respected with the need to make the right calls?

Clark
Reply With Quote