Quote:
Originally posted by cbfoulds
R3, 2 out; tie score, bottom of the final inning.
BR hits to the gap; R3 scores & BR reaches 1st safely.
Game over, Home team wins, right? BUT WAIT!!
BR "retreats" from 1st to join the celebration around the plte, defense throws to 1st baseman who holds the ball securely in hand or glove while in contact with the base. (Or tags BR, actually, either works)
If the play @ 1st is a force and "retreating" toward home "reinstates the force", then the run doesn't score - 3 outs, bring on the next half-inning, score's still tied. This could go on for a while.
The play at 1st is NOT a "force", although, yes indeedie, BR has an "obligation" to advance. If BR reaches and touches 1st before being put out, but (being a typical bonehead) retreats toward home for some reason HE (not the base) must be tagged to make the out; and if the tag should happen to be the 3rd out, any run which reached the plate before the time of the tag WILL SCORE.
There is, in fact, a reason for everything.
|
Given your made up situation, my ruling stands. The bonehead retreated, reinstating the FORCE, and if defense plays on him the run does not score. Why am I supposed to protect the team with boneheads? Do you think I would call that in this situation? When then run crosses home and the batter makes it 1b, I don't see anything else happen, hypothetical or otherwise.