Thread: Balk ruling
View Single Post
  #3 (permalink)  
Old Sat Jun 05, 2004, 01:46pm
David B David B is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 1,772
That's what I'm thinking also

Quote:
Originally posted by Delaware Blue
Sure sounds like a balk to me...

the coach said that they had done this all season long (in HS), and no one had called it a balk.

Interesting since FED rules prohibit F1 from throwing to a base from the wind up. He may only pitch to the batter or step off. In FED, any throw to a base from the wind up position without legally disengaging first is a balk.

OBR allows the pitcher to throw to a base from the wind up as long as he steps directly to the base and makes no move normally associated with the delivery of the pitch.

From J/R
It is a balk if a pitcher:
Commits to pitch but fails to do so. Windup Mode: The pitcher is committed to pitch when there is a movement or step of his non-pivot foot. His joining of hands without movement of either foot does not commit the pitcher to pitch.

It is not a balk if a pitcher steps to: Third, second, or first base from the windup position (without beginning any wind-up motion)...
Yes, he did step back with his pivot foot first which the coach said makes him an infielder.

I agree with that, but he still has to abide by FED which prohits him making moves naturally associated with a pitch.

I'm also going to talk with several of our umpires who did NOT call it a balk and see what they were thinking.

We will be sure and correct this by next season

Thanks
David
Reply With Quote