Quote:
Originally posted by Jim S
Quote:
Originally posted by sm_bbcoach
Play take from POD 5-3:
Ruling given: If penality is declines, the IW during the loose ball dictiates replay of down. (I agree!)
If penality is accepted, the fould negates the IW and results in a PREVIOUS SPOT enforcement.
Why, then, does the penality negate the IW? It would seem to me that if accepted, either PSK should coe into play and R keeps ball but looses 10 yrd (1/2 distance) OR you replay down w/ NO yardage markoff.
|
From where did you get this?
I want to see their justification. I would agree that the choices are to decline the foul, thereby replaying the down at the previous spot (no foul yardage, it was declined.
Or, to accept the foul, which is a PSK foul, ignore the IW rules, and enforce from, in this case, the spot the ball became dead. Result B 1&10 from the B8
|
This was the Play of the Day for 5-3-04. I have sent 2 e-mails to them asking for a justification, but no reply .
It just does not make ANY sence at all!
Can anyone from NF help on this. Usually, if POD make a mistake they will own up to it the next day or so.