Quote:
Originally posted by ChuckElias
Quote:
Originally posted by Jurassic Referee
Blindzebra's quote was "Chuck is talking about taking one for the team. If two defenders are there, the one with the fewer fouls gets the foul. Who hit A harder or first does NOT enter the picture".
|
And I said he's exactly right. Ok, I see your point. I took him to be speaking generally, about the normal course of play, like the usual situation where a shooter gets hit by two defenders at roughly the same time with about the same amount of contact. You took him literally to mean that the level of contact never matters.
|
If you look way back on p2, he was answering a very plain, literal and specific question that I put forth- i.e. "Do you take into account that the contact from one player may be stronger than another, and that this contact rarely occurs exactly simultaneously?".As per his answer above relating to that question, he replied that it DOES NOT matter who hit the player harder or first. You just give the foul to the player who has he fewer fouls. That's what you agreed with, Chuck. I took him literally because that was his answer to a literal and specific question.