Quote:
Originally posted by mnref14
Jurassic - As officials we're not allowed to second-guess each other?????
|
Yes,we are.However, I've been trying very hard not to second-guess you here, but you're making it awful difficult. Why won't
you answer any simple questions?
Let me try again:
Please give me just one instance out of the 19 T's issued by Ref18 where you are sure he was wrong to issue that T. Not all 19- just one! Then give me your reasoning or opinion as to exactly why Ref18
was wrong to issue a T in that particular case. In other words, tell us why that coach's behavior didn't really warrant a T in that particular case, and what you would have done in lieu of issuing that T. Remember- you don't have to do that for all 19 T's that you disagree with. Just pick one. You are completely adamant that Ref18 was wrong to issue those T's, so I would just like to know exactly what you are basing your opinion on. I await your answer, so that we can continue our delightful conversation.
Btw, don't mind Dan. He can be a little crude at times, but he means well. He doesn't have the presence, elan and
savoir faire of a complete official like yourself, but his personal growth in the last little while has been amazing (even if he still has a potty mouth).