View Single Post
  #6 (permalink)  
Old Fri Dec 12, 2003, 08:37am
bob jenkins bob jenkins is offline
Official Forum Member
 
Join Date: Aug 1999
Posts: 18,190
Re: the same, yet different

Quote:
Originally posted by TH_indiana
had a similar sitch tonite. I was R, partner was U (he is more experienced than I am fyi). I call a two shot foul on A1. I am administering the FT, I bounce to shooter B1. Shooter dribbles, starts motion, and JUST before he releases the ball for the shot, the table blows the horn, indicating the 5th foul on A1. B1 continues his motion, releases the shot, my partner blows his whistle while shot is in the air. Ball goes in, partner waves off shot. Comes to me. I say 'don't blow your whistle after I have already given ball to player. Table was late to inform us. Shot is good" He says "No, the player is DQ'd and must leave the floor before we can shoot, we will will "re-shoot" the first shot." Not wanting to argue I just go along. Coach of B (who is winning big btw) questions my partner but doesn't put up too much fuss.
What is correct procedure here?

Since the try was in the air when the whistle blew, the try counts.

Make the sub for the DQ'd player, and shoot the second throw.

It's not a correctable error.


Reply With Quote