Quote:
Originally Posted by Tru_in_Blu
TB21, my book has 2(a) "the hit is a live, ground ball." That's for the one that deflects off the top of the fence and lands in the outfield.
If it's the one where the ball hits the fence bounces up and lands on the other side of the fence, it's a HR.
I've read the rulings for Situation S and have no problem with any of them.
Can you clarify?
|
Page 61; 2019 case book. I think I created confusion by labeling my examples ABC before citing the case book.
In my OP; my 2(a) corresponds with Case Play 8.4.3.S(d). Ball hits the top of the fence and goes over. My 2(c) is a variant of this, as well.
My 2(b) corresponds with CP 8.4.3.S(b).
Here's the problem I have with the interps: A ball that strikes the top of the fence in fair territory is simultaneously a ground ball (it cannot be caught by a fielder for a fly out) and a fair fly ball (if it goes over untouched, it's a HR).