Quote:
Originally Posted by BillyMac
I get it. Not sure I agree, but I get the logic and the rule language behind it.
Because it's not a real violation, the "violation" doesn't cause the ball to became dead, it's the inadvertent whistle that causes the ball to become dead and the whistle may be slightly delayed (as it always is).
I would like to see further discussion before I change my mind, especially the part about counting the basket (after the ring hit but also after the sound of the whistle).
If everybody's going to count that basket, then I better think about backing up the truck and moving in another direction.
Good discussion guys. I can certainly see your logic.
Maybe Basketball Rules Fundamental 16 isn't as clear as I once believed.
|
Again, it depends on the status of the ball when the inadvertent whistle occurs. If the IW occurs after the defender gained possession, his team gets the ball because they had team control. If the player was in the act of shooting but the ball was not released-same result. If the try was released and then the IW occurs we use the arrow if the try was unsuccessful. If the try was good the basket counts and play resumes from there. See 7.5.3