Rick posted:
"Here's a different scenario, but the same rule(s) should apply, I think. If a runner on 1st steals 2nd. The catcher overthrows the defense. The runner goes to 3rd, rounds it and is heading home when the coach tells her to go back to 2nd. She goes straight to 2nd and gets there safely. (Remember, this is 10-U.) The defense should be able to appeal the runner missing 3rd base, correct? This is the same at home. I'm sure I'll hear some debate on this and am looking forward to reading and maybe learning a little more."
Rick
I agree with the above, however original scenario, was that the
10U runner had achieved HP. There is no where else for her to go.
After the play the umpire would put her back on 3rd, even if she has
headed for dugout or even entered it. She is not abandoning
a base, merely completing what she figured to be a run scored.
Above scenario is different and even 10U would be required to comply
with Rule 8 Sec 3A. unless runner is standing on 3rd at time of
tag.
glen