The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Softball (https://forum.officiating.com/softball/)
-   -   Charged Conference (https://forum.officiating.com/softball/99681-charged-conference.html)

benbret Wed Apr 15, 2015 04:56pm

Charged Conference
 
NFHS Varsity girls. The coach of home team has used his 3 visits. On the fourth visit the coach is told he must replace F1. Can he/she switch F5 and F1 for 1 pitch and then bring the starting F1 back to pitch.

Found answer!!
Penalty: (ART. 1) After three charged conferences in a seven-inning game, or for any charged conference in excess of one in each extra inning, the pitcher shall be removed as pitcher for the duration of the game.

Dakota Wed Apr 15, 2015 06:11pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by benbret (Post 960989)
NFHS Varsity girls. The coach of home team has used his 3 visits. On the fourth visit the coach is told he must replace F1. Can he/she switch F5 and F1 for 1 pitch and then bring the starting F1 back to pitch.

Found answer!!
Penalty: (ART. 1) After three charged conferences in a seven-inning game, or for any charged conference in excess of one in each extra inning, the pitcher shall be removed as pitcher for the duration of the game.

Glad we could help! :D

EsqUmp Thu Apr 16, 2015 06:27am

This is a terribly written rule. They mirrored ASA, who botched it up tremendously when they changed it from one per inning. A sorry excuse to speed up the game left gaping holes in the rule.

Skahtboi Thu Apr 16, 2015 06:35am

Quote:

Originally Posted by benbret (Post 960989)
NFHS Varsity girls. The coach of home team has used his 3 visits. On the fourth visit the coach is told he must replace F1. Can he/she switch F5 and F1 for 1 pitch and then bring the starting F1 back to pitch.

Found answer!!
Penalty: (ART. 1) After three charged conferences in a seven-inning game, or for any charged conference in excess of one in each extra inning, the pitcher shall be removed as pitcher for the duration of the game.

Sorry it took so much discussion and so long for us to reach a consensus on this one. :D

Andy Thu Apr 16, 2015 11:41am

Quote:

Originally Posted by EsqUmp (Post 961012)
This is a terribly written rule. They mirrored ASA, who botched it up tremendously when they changed it from one per inning. A sorry excuse to speed up the game left gaping holes in the rule.

Please explain....

IRISHMAFIA Thu Apr 16, 2015 12:06pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andy (Post 961019)
Please explain....

Yeah, NFHS' has a bit of overkill to address different scenarios seemingly created by unnecessary "what if" scenarios. However, I'd like to hear what is so poor about the wording of ASA's. Seems pretty clear to me.

CecilOne Thu Apr 16, 2015 07:53pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by EsqUmp (Post 961012)
This is a terribly written rule. They mirrored ASA, who botched it up tremendously when they changed it from one per inning. A sorry excuse to speed up the game left gaping holes in the rule.

How is it different than PONY or others?

Dakota Fri Apr 17, 2015 11:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by CecilOne (Post 961033)
How is it different than PONY or others?

'Cause it's the evil empire, don'tcha know! :cool:

chapmaja Fri Apr 17, 2015 11:40am

Here is a what if on the charged conference rule.

Team A has used 3 charged conferences early in the game. In the fifth inning the coach comes out to talk to the pitcher. After talking to the pitcher, the coach walks toward the dugout and tells S1 she is going in to pitch. She says this right as the umpire goes to approach the coach about it being a third charged conference.

Is this a third charged conference or not? (because of the timing of the change vs the conference?) Does F1 have the ability to return as pitcher? What about S1 if the team uses another charged conference later?

youngump Fri Apr 17, 2015 11:44am

Quote:

Originally Posted by chapmaja (Post 961049)
Here is a what if on the charged conference rule.

Team A has used 2 charged conferences early in the game. In the fifth inning the coach comes out to talk to the pitcher. After talking to the pitcher, the coach walks toward the dugout and tells S1 she is going in to pitch. She says this right as the umpire goes to approach the coach about it being a third charged conference.

Is this a third charged conference or not? (because of the timing of the change vs the conference?) Does F1 have the ability to return as pitcher? What about S1 if the team uses another charged conference later?

So the easy part of your question, this is only the third conference so F1 has the ability to come back in regardless of whether it's charged. If the team uses another charged conference while S1 is the pitcher, then we have the penalty.

chapmaja Fri Apr 17, 2015 11:50am

Quote:

Originally Posted by youngump (Post 961050)
So the easy part of your question, this is only the third conference so F1 has the ability to come back in regardless of whether it's charged. If the team uses another charged conference while S1 is the pitcher, then we have the penalty.

Helps if I write the question correctly? I meant to say they had used three (not two) earlier. I will edit the original post.

RKBUmp Fri Apr 17, 2015 12:19pm

Nfhs and asa it is not a charged conference if the coach changes pitchers. There is no requirement the coach notify the umpire first there is going to be a pitching change.

MD Longhorn Fri Apr 17, 2015 01:03pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by chapmaja (Post 961049)
Here is a what if on the charged conference rule.

Team A has used 3 charged conferences early in the game. In the fifth inning the coach comes out to talk to the pitcher. After talking to the pitcher, the coach walks toward the dugout and tells S1 she is going in to pitch. She says this right as the umpire goes to approach the coach about it being a third charged conference.

Is this a third charged conference or not? (because of the timing of the change vs the conference?) Does F1 have the ability to return as pitcher? What about S1 if the team uses another charged conference later?

No. You don't get two third conferences. This is a 4th charged conference, and as such you should have been out there almost immediately.

Andy Fri Apr 17, 2015 05:09pm

If coach has used all three of his conferences and asks for time to go out and talk to his pitcher, this is where you get involved immediately.

"Coach, this will be your fourth conference. If you go out, your pitcher is done as the pitcher."

If he acknowledges that, let him go and then get the change.
If he has lost track and decides not to take the conference, play ball.

teebob21 Fri Apr 17, 2015 08:14pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andy (Post 961055)
If coach has used all three of his conferences and asks for time to go out and talk to his pitcher, this is where you get involved immediately.

"Coach, this will be your fourth conference. If you go out, your pitcher is done as the pitcher."

If he acknowledges that, let him go and then get the change.
If he has lost track and decides not to take the conference, play ball.

Now drifting into lineup card management, what is the best practice to mark the card when this happens? I keep a list on the back of the team's card with the conference type, inning and player numbers if I can get it.

Example from a recent game card:

Code:

Offcon 2 #4
OC 3 #15
OC 4 BR #33 + runners

Defcon 3 Team
DC 4 F1@circle

Should I just write #46 MAY NOT PITCH after the 4th conference?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:18am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1